NPR’s Leila Fadel speaks with sports activities doctor Jordan Metzl about President Trump’s effort to revive the Presidential Health Take a look at.
LEILA FADEL, HOST:
The presidential health take a look at is coming again. You keep in mind that, proper? Faculty age youngsters being evaluated on pushups, situps, operating, rope climbs and different workouts for greater than 50 years. I discovered it traumatic, however I digress. Then the Obama administration revamped it. And President Trump hasn’t but introduced what his new analysis will seem like or when it will likely be carried out. However we thought we might ask concerning the prospects. Dr. Jordan Metzl is a sports activities drugs doctor on the Hospital for Particular Surgical procedure in New York and joins me now. Good morning.
JORDAN METZL: Good morning to you.
FADEL: So is there advantage to bringing again a presidential health take a look at?
METZL: I feel that is a terrific query. And it is unclear. The presidential bodily health take a look at was began by President Kennedy again within the Sixties. And the concept was that American children had been watching an excessive amount of tv, they usually had been sitting round getting unfit. And so the concept was to implement a method to guage their health and encourage health in them. And also you and I and many people went by means of presidential bodily health testing…
FADEL: (Laughter).
METZL: …As a approach of evaluating the place we had been.
FADEL: Did you additionally sit on the backside of the rope? As a result of I could not climb it (laughter).
METZL: That was the method. Precisely.
FADEL: Is a presidential health take a look at, although, a great way to shut that hole that you simply described with children watching extra TV and all this?
METZL: Yeah, effectively, in in the present day’s age, we’re coping with smartphones and inactivity in children. And I feel it is unclear whether or not having a metric to guage them will make them extra energetic. However definitely, that was the thought again within the ’60s as effectively.
FADEL: How a lot of a priority about inactive children is admittedly new?
METZL: I feel the priority is identical, nevertheless it’s getting worse. In the US, we’ve got 80% of our children beneath the age of 18, in keeping with the CDC, should not assembly really helpful bodily health exercise pointers. And we’ve got greater than 20% of our inhabitants beneath the age of 18 which are overweight. And so we’re searching for methods to encourage children to get match and energetic, and whether or not it is a take a look at or no matter it’s, we undoubtedly want to consider encouraging children as a result of athletic and energetic children turn out to be athletic teenagers who turn out to be athletic adults, who’ve a complete host of well being advantages from exercise and a complete host of well being dangers from inactivity. So this can be a actually necessary paradigm to.
FADEL: However is that this the reply, an analysis the place you place children beneath a microscope? I simply keep in mind feeling like, oh, man, I obtained to attempt to faux to do pushups once more.
METZL: (Laughter) I do not assume we all know the reply to that query. I feel that there is no precise reply. I feel it is, , we have to begin encouraging exercise in our younger individuals, whether or not it is a take a look at or no matter it’s, we have to begin serious about methods to do this. And I feel that is the main target.
FADEL: OK, so we do not actually know what this revived health take a look at would seem like. However what would it not take to achieve success? I imply, what would you need to see in it?
METZL: I feel the important thing factor, , when you keep in mind from the previous days once we did this as effectively, that this must be one thing that is reproducible in high-income, low-income, medium-income faculties as a result of faculties have completely different means across the nation. And so one factor there must be is it needs to be primarily low-tech or no tech.
And once more, like getting your blood strain taken or no matter while you go to a health care provider, it isn’t the worth on the day that makes a distinction, although it does, nevertheless it’s actually the place you might be in comparison with final 12 months and the 12 months earlier than while you go to your annual checkup. And so the concept right here is, are we giving one thing that is reproducible 12 months after 12 months? And are we giving individuals one thing to shoot for? So I do not assume the idea is a horrible idea. I simply assume it needs to be carried out appropriately.
FADEL: And actually shortly, I imply, is there something – I imply, this went on for 50 years. Is there something from many years of information on this previous take a look at that you could study from?
METZL: I feel that we have to encourage individuals to be energetic. I do not assume we’ve got any particular knowledge. That is, in actual fact, the purpose. However getting individuals energetic is the important thing message.
FADEL: Dr. Jordan Metzl is a sports activities drugs doctor on the Hospital for Particular Surgical procedure in New York. He is additionally the writer of the guide “The Train Treatment.” Thanks to your time.
METZL: Thanks a lot.
(SOUNDBITE OF DAVY GRAHAM’S “ANGI”)
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could differ. Transcript textual content could also be revised to right errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its authentic broadcast or publication. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.
